The two models in one paragraph
Temp-to-hire: the staffing agency employs the worker, payrolls them, and covers workers comp. After a probationary period (usually 480 or 520 hours), you can convert the worker to your own W-2 with no conversion fee — or let them go without any of the friction of a traditional termination. Direct placement: the staffing agency sources, screens, and presents candidates. You hire them directly from day one, and pay the agency a one-time flat fee (typically a percentage of first-year salary).
When temp-to-hire makes sense
- High-volume warehouse, light-industrial, and production roles
- Seasonal hiring spikes (Q4 retail, summer hospitality)
- Roles where culture fit is hard to judge from a resume
- Businesses that want to flex workforce up and down by 10–30% without permanent headcount
- Any role where the risk of a bad hire is high relative to the cost of waiting
The big advantage is risk transfer: if the worker doesn't work out, you simply end the assignment. No unemployment claim, no severance, no awkward HR conversation.
When direct placement makes sense
- Salaried professional roles (engineering, finance, management)
- Skilled trades where the candidate market is competitive
- Roles where a candidate would be insulted to be hired through a temp model
- Long-tenured roles where you want the worker on your benefits and 401(k) from day one
For most professional and skilled-trades hires in Vermont, direct placement is the right model. The flat percentage fee is a small fraction of the cost of a bad hire or an unfilled six-month vacancy.
The math, side by side
Temp-to-hire (40-hr/week role at $22/hr base wage): you'd pay roughly $32–34/hr bill rate. That covers the wage, payroll taxes, workers comp, and the agency margin. After the conversion period, you take the worker onto your books at the base wage.
Direct placement (same role): you'd pay $22/hr from day one, plus a one-time fee of 18–25% of first-year compensation. For a $45,000 role, that's roughly $8–11k due at hire.
Over a full year, temp-to-hire is more expensive on a per-hour basis but flexes with you. Direct placement is cheaper long-term but commits you to the headcount.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a conversion fee for temp-to-hire?+
Most reputable Vermont staffing agencies (VEA included) charge no conversion fee after the agreed probationary period — usually 480 or 520 hours worked.
How fast can a staffing agency send candidates?+
For most temp and temp-to-hire roles, qualified candidates are submitted within 48 hours. Direct-placement searches usually take 5–10 days.
Need to hire? We’ll respond today.
Tell us the role. A Vermont recruiter responds within one business hour during work hours.